Welcome, Guest. Please Login
MCD - Mast Cell Disorders
  Signup for free on our forum and benefit from new features!
  HomeHelpSearchLogin  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences (Read 5287 times)
Futurehope
Mentor
****
Offline



Posts: 357
Clermont, Florida
I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
04/09/13 at 10:18:09
 
I have tried several H2's, zantac, pepcid, tagamet.  I don't notice much except maybe it helps decrease the incidence of heartburn in concert with my PPI?

Claritin - nothing

I haven't tried Allegra yet.

If I discontinue the Hydroxyzine HCL, my bladder pain becomes unbearable as I seem to react to various foods.

So, Hydroxyzine HCL seems to be the only med with obvious benefits for me. I need to be on this pill daily, or else symptoms start up.

Unfortunately, taking this pill is causing increasing side effects the older I get:  forgetfulness, drowsiness, tiredness, increase in restless leg syndrome symptoms.

I am caught between a rock and a hard place: I can't live with the Hydroxyzine HCL, I can't live without it.

Question for forum members:

Is there a med that you know you have to take on a daily basis, or else your symptoms increase? Is it obvious that if you stop the med, you get worse?  Does the said med cause you side effects?  If so, what are they?

I feel like I have to turn into a walking, tired zombie so that I can live pain free.  This is not fun....being reactive to many foods and finding that the only help is causing me uncomfortable issues.

I want to see if anyone else has to "put up" with a medicine on a daily basis that causes them side effects?

Thanks in advance.

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
DeborahW, Founder
FOUNDER/ADMIN
********
Offline



Posts: 1224
USA
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #1 - 04/10/13 at 03:20:46
 
You didn't mention trying Zyrtec, and you said that you haven't tried Allegra yet. Those are the 2 best substitutes for Hydroxyzine. For me Hydroxyzine is an emergency medicine when I am headed toward anaphylaxis. Otherwise, I take 180 mg Allegra in the morning and 10 mg zyrtec around 4 pm. I also take Zantac at those times. For years I took 300 mg of Zantac in the morning and at 4pm. Now that I do so well, I take 150 mg each time.

I believe that you might have not yet tried the right combination of meds yet. Thus you are stuck with taking the stronger med, Hydrozyzine. That is an older med, while the ones I mentioned are newer and this have fewer side effects. You mention bladder pain, which is curious because most of us get abdominal pain. So I wonder if you meant that or really bladder. Typically the combination of Zantac, Allegra, and Zyrtec will dramatically help and is a common combo for mast cell docs to use before switching us to more powerful things if needed.

I would highly recommend trying these meds, however just add one at a time for a week at a time so that you can make sure you react fine. Most people have no problems with these meds, so I wouldn't worry or expect that you would have any problems. Once you have built up to the Zantac, Zyrtec, and Allegra, see how you do. I'm not sure when to suggest cutting out the Hydroxyzine, but I would so that very slowly. For example, if you take it twice a day, perhaps lower the dose of one of those times for a week. Then lower the dose of the other time for a week. If you are doing well still, the. Wean yourself off it more by cutting out a dose, perhaps the morning one. Continue along in that manner until you are off. I weaned myself down slowly with my Zantac dose and had no ill effects as opposed to just stopping the med cold turkey.
Back to top
 

Feel well!
DeborahW, founder
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Futurehope
Mentor
****
Offline



Posts: 357
Clermont, Florida
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #2 - 04/10/13 at 04:09:19
 
So Deb, are you saying that it is okay to stay on the Hydroxyzine HCL while I am trying the Allegra?  IOW, I can be taking both at the same time?

I do have the Allegra in the house, as well as Xyzal (which is like zyrtec).

I did not know that I could remain on the Hydroxyzine HCL while I was trying the Allegra?!

Thanks so much for giving me your ideas.

Yes, I frequently have stomach pain as well as bladder pain. I have both.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
DeborahW, Founder
FOUNDER/ADMIN
********
Offline



Posts: 1224
USA
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #3 - 04/10/13 at 04:52:38
 
I assume you can take all at the same time because my instructions were to take the Hydroxyzine for emergency if I had already tried doubling my Allegra and Zyrtec and that didnt work. HOWEVER, I don't know if you would be more fatigued or not because some people feel tired from the Zyrtec (I don't). Just a baby dose of Hydrozyzine for me, though, practically knocks me out! That is why I will do everything to avoid Hydroxyzine. It works, but I feel like I have a hangover the next 2 days after taking it! Some people say they build up a tolerance for that effect, but that is the reason I think it important to wean down from it to avoid any withdrawal type symptoms.

If I were you, I would call your pharmacist and ask if it is okay to take Hydroxyzine and Allegra or Zyrtec. Keep in mind, pharmacists don't understand mast cell disease, so they will give you the "normal person" answer. Then you have to adapt it to the mast cell person answer. For example, a pharmacist would tell me I could take 1 Zyrtec or 1 Allegra a day. In reality, though, my doc, Dr Akin has me on 1 of each per day and I can double both of them same day when flaring (so essentially could take 2 Zyrtec and 2 Allegra all on one day). A pharmacist would never advise that, but they don't know mast cell disease like a world renowned mast cell specialist does.

Since Zyrtec can cause some drowsiness for some people, perhaps you could try an Allegra this morning and do that for a week and see how it goes.
Back to top
 

Feel well!
DeborahW, founder
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Starflower
FORUM ADVISOR
*****
Offline


Not a medical doctor
Posts: 715
Indiana
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #4 - 04/10/13 at 12:17:21
 
I agree with Deb.  There's no harm in trying a different H1 like Zyrtec or Allegra (either one is an excellent choice).  If it's not helping... and you still need hydroxyzine that day... just add it back in.  You won't overdose.

Personally, I take 4X the normal dose of H1s on a daily basis... a mix of Zyrtec (day) and Benadryl (night).  Claritin works well for me too, but some mast cell patients find that it's not effective enough.  When I have a flare or I need to pre-medicate... for exercise, travel, etc... I've taken as much as 3-4 doses of H1 on top of my regular dose!  Ditto for the H2s.  The only negative side effect I've experienced is a dry mouth.  You would have to take a really crazy amount of antihistamines to overdose.  It's not like pain medication.

Heather  
Back to top
 

We're all in this thing together
Walkin' the line between faith and fear
This life don't last forever
When you cry I taste the salt in your tears
(Old Crow Medicine Show)
 
IP Logged
 
Futurehope
Mentor
****
Offline



Posts: 357
Clermont, Florida
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #5 - 04/10/13 at 14:03:54
 
Okay, I spoke to a pharmacist because it seems like taking all the H1's is like I would be ODing.

The pharmacist told me that my Hydroxyzine HCL works differently than the Allegra.

You are all making me feel more comfortable in trying the Allegra.

I would put up with a dry mouth if necessary if it allowed me to decrease my Hydroxyzine HCL.  I am recalling that Dr. Afrin, or his secretary, were suggesting not to decrease my Hydroxyzine HCL (which I know works really well for me), until after I've added in the Claritin or Allegra.  

I'm certain I'm supposed to be taking an H2 twice/day as well.

The question I have is:  I've taken an H2 (zantac) twice/day and I do not notice anything?!  How do I know if I'm supposed to stay on it or forget  about it? I don't get why I am taking something yet I do not see the benefit?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
DeborahW, Founder
FOUNDER/ADMIN
********
Offline



Posts: 1224
USA
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #6 - 04/10/13 at 17:50:01
 
The Zantac cannot fix you GI pain all by itself.  It should be helping calm mast cells down, but it needs to H1 meds to assist it. You also might not be on a high enough dose. What dose do you take, and how often do you take it?


Lastly, it is important to note that meds alone will not fix the problem completely. To get to a state where mast cell issues are more of an afterthought, one must change diet and lifestyle to avoid as many triggers as possible.
Back to top
 

Feel well!
DeborahW, founder
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Futurehope
Mentor
****
Offline



Posts: 357
Clermont, Florida
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #7 - 04/10/13 at 23:05:40
 
Deb, right now I only take 1 Zantac/day  in the PM.  It is 150 MG. I know I'm supposed to be on it twice/day.

I just took my first Allegra this morning.  I'll see how that goes before increasing the Zantac.

Thanks for answering my questions about whether or not I need a pill whose benefit I cannot notice,  i.e. the Zantac.  I guess from what you are saying and from what Dr. Afrin recommends, I need both an H1 and an H2 regardless?

I am trying to get a handle on all this.  And yes, I will have to restrict my diet more.  I already avoid many things on the anti-histamine diet because I know those foods create problems for me.  I still ingest some other items I should not.  I find lunch most difficult.  I guess I'll have to resort to cream cheese on bread without preservatives?

Anyhow, for now, I must get out of this flare.  And yes, my bladder pain can become intense.  It's as if I have a urinary tract infection.

The bladder stuff began in my 20's.  I can go for a while without problems, but am noticing the older I get, the bladder issue manifests itself more easily and more frequently. So, as far as I can tell, this mast cell disease got worse over time.

I need all those pills, to stay stable. At a younger age, the flares were fewer and further apart, and the meds were not needed on a continuous basis.  Oh the joys of getting older  Huh

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
DeborahW, Founder
FOUNDER/ADMIN
********
Offline



Posts: 1224
USA
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #8 - 04/11/13 at 00:51:19
 
I'm glad I can help. I mainly offer suggestions when I really feel that it will be of assistance. So, given that, I would say that now that I know you only take Zantac 150mg once a day, then that seems to be an obvious reason as to why you see no benefits. When you are able, I would suggest increasing it to 300 mg twice a day. I still am unclear as to if bladder pain is a result of mast cells because I have never heard anyone mention it. That doesn't mean it isn't! We all have slightly different symptoms just like we all can eat different foods. In fact, don't use the histamine diet as your bible, because it is so individual for people. There are things on that diet I can eat and other things there that would kill me. I kept a food diary to determine my safe foods.

In a good note, with the right meds and lifestyle, your mast cell disease can eat better! Mine has dramatically improved. I am so much better that I used to be; it's amazing. Plus I can lead a near normal life! I am lacking energy that normal people have, but that's okay! I never go into anaphylaxis anymore and I rarely have GI pain (and that was always one of my worst things). I actual think I am doing much better now than ever before, and I attribute it to the basic meds of Zantac, Allegra, and Zyrtec, and my efforts to watch what I eat and to maintain as low stress lifestyle as possible. I think this is achievable by many, and I hope that you get to this level too!
Back to top
 

Feel well!
DeborahW, founder
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Futurehope
Mentor
****
Offline



Posts: 357
Clermont, Florida
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #9 - 04/11/13 at 03:46:54
 
I hope so too.  So far, I tried the 180 MG Allegra, and I've had a horrible headache.  So, I don't know whether I should give up right now, or try 1/2 Allegra tomorrow morning instead of a whole one?

I've just taken a (new) morning Zantac 150 as well, but I already had the headache after taking the Allegra, so I believe it is from that.

Yes, Dr. Afrin thinks that my interstitial cystitis pain is from my mast cell disease, especially since it responds so well to the Hydroxyzine HCL. My bladder pain is a definite marker for me that I am not doing well.

You are correct in that following a histamine free diet list may not be necessary, since everyone is so different.  My only hope is to really test foods out so that I can notice which are okay and which are not.

I am assuming that if a food is okay, I should not get stomach problems, headaches, stuffy nose, extreme drowsiness or anything else unusual if the food is okay for me, right?

I am looking forward to a more stable future.  Right now stomach upsets, headaches, and chronic fatigue are the norm.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
DeborahW, Founder
FOUNDER/ADMIN
********
Offline



Posts: 1224
USA
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #10 - 04/11/13 at 04:40:24
 
A few things come to mind. First, remember that not just foods cause those symptoms. Environmental things, such as heat or cold cause problems in many. So does stress.

In regard to the headache today, do you live in the US? If so, are you in the path of any of the storms moving across the country? Storms will cause major headaches, so you have to be careful in considering if it is a storm or the Allegra or something else.
Back to top
 

Feel well!
DeborahW, founder
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Futurehope
Mentor
****
Offline



Posts: 357
Clermont, Florida
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #11 - 04/11/13 at 06:02:24
 
Very true.  AS of right now, I'm thinking my headache was a kind of withdrawal from my usual breakfast foods.  I'm trying to eat only safe foods until my bladder simmers does, so I completely switched up my foods.

It is probably related to withdrawing from foods, because after I ate some other foods for lunch, the headache disappeared.

You are right, my body "notices" decreasing barometric pressure.  I could get a stuffy nose or headache-y.

I'll try the Allegra again tomorrow AM.  After a few days, I'll add a nighttime dose.

I cannot tell you how much I value your input.  I feel so lost and in need of guidance right now, and any help I get is greatly appreciated. Thank you from the bottom of my heart.

Here's to a better future for me!

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
DeborahW, Founder
FOUNDER/ADMIN
********
Offline



Posts: 1224
USA
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #12 - 04/12/13 at 03:08:13
 
You are very welcome! Make sure to come back to this thread and let me know how you are doing with this medicine experiment! Smiley
Back to top
 

Feel well!
DeborahW, founder
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Futurehope
Mentor
****
Offline



Posts: 357
Clermont, Florida
Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #13 - 04/12/13 at 04:01:35
 
Day two, Allegra still caused the same sick headache, but not quite as intense as on day one.  Should I just skip a day all together, and then try one half an Allegra next time? Or should I DC it all together forever?

I'm not used to all this methodical experimenting. Any advice is welcome.

ETA:  Sarah, I read your PM and I'm glad you shared your experience.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
KatFromMD
Ex Member





Re: I Notice a Benefit From Only One Medicine - I'm Interested in Your Experiences
Reply #14 - 04/12/13 at 05:52:29
 
I've never heard of anyone reacting to Allegra, but we are all so different that I wouldn't rule it out.  It could also be that you're stressed about taking it, and the STRESS is causing the headache!  If you can tough it out, I try to give everything at least a week's try.  You often can get past initial symptoms as your body adjusts.  Just don't make yourself miserable.

I take 1 Allegra and 300mg Zantac THREE times a day.  I try to take them a half hour before eating to reduce GI symptoms.  I do notice that occasionally if I haven't eaten in a long time and take them, and then don't eat after a half hour, I can get really nauseous and feel weird.  So, I would recommend food with these things to keep you on a more even keel.  I've noticed the timing of taking them before meals doesn't seem nearly as important now that I'm more stable, I just need to take them three times a day.

Also, I will back up Deb on the surprising fact that the H1 and H2 really do work together.  I found that my urticaria had further improvement from the increase in H2, which you wouldn't think would make sense.  I saw only the slightest GI improvement on 150mg of Zantac twice a day, and it wasn't until I was up on the dose I am now, and on the really restricted diet, that I got any kind of relief from GI issues.   The dose you're on right now, I wouldn't expect it to do much of anything.  The key is to bump it up some and see if you get even slight improvement.   Then you can decide to bump it more.  Again, only change one med a week, and if you stop one, get back to steady-state before trying another.

And that cream cheese and bread will get some added flavor from sliced cucumber!  (That's my go-to lunch these days!)  Snack on a side-dish of sugar snap peas and maybe some rice crackers.

And since misery loves company, I'll share my latest med experiment fun with you: You know I was trying aspirin and initially seemed to be getting some benefit from it.  Well, I started having issues beyond just the bruising: cold numb limbs, hot flashes and chills, and worst of all, difficulty breathing.  I stopped the aspirin a week ago and the doctor put me on a steroid inhaler, but I'm still having trouble breathing with any type of exertion (i.e. walking upstairs) or fragrance exposure.  But you know, this crap happens.  I'm still glad I tried the aspirin because I do think it helped, especially with getting my blood pressure up.  This tells me that I should at some point try a different NSAID.  For now, I think I'd like to try Singulair next, because this latest episode has just brought my long-standing breathing issues to the fore, and maybe we should try to address them.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print