Welcome, Guest. Please Login
MCD - Mast Cell Disorders
  Welcome to our forum.
  HomeHelpSearchLogin  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia (Read 15762 times)
larken
Guiding Light
***
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 136

Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
02/15/11 at 18:54:15
 
I am wondering if anyone knows doctors or researchers who are building on Dr Blanco et al's study last year on the high level of spindle-shaped mast cells in the skin of fibro patients.

I was diagnosed with fibro in 1997.  My symptoms are now much more in line with MCAD.  I'm not sure if I have both or was misdiagnosed earlier.  

I read Lisa's post about Dr Blanco in Spain and his forced retirement by the government as a result of the financial crisis.  I am really surprised and upset that he is losing his job and that we may lose his expertise (and hope he can find someplace else to practice, if that is what he wants to do).  

Does anyone know of studies building on his research or looking at other angles of the connection--perhaps a causative link--between mast cells and fibro?   Or, doctors who believe there is a connection?

Thanks,
Larken
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
missybean
Mentor
****
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 439
Washington
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #1 - 02/16/11 at 04:04:28
 
I'm really interested in this as I was diagnosed with Fibro last year and I'm wondering if I was misdiagnosed as well.
Melissa
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
DeborahW, Founder
FOUNDER/ADMIN
********
Offline



Posts: 1224
USA
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #2 - 02/23/11 at 02:25:43
 
This Topic was moved here from Medicines by DeborahW, Founder.
Back to top
 

Feel well!
DeborahW, founder
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Josie
Ex Member





Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #3 - 02/25/11 at 04:58:13
 
Hi Missy Bean and larken ,

I too have a fibro diagnosis . I also have my doubts about my diagnosis Smiley as i was diagnosed earlier in my illness and all my symptoms have other explinations . Even my fibro friends have questioned my diagnosis .

But I read Dr Blancos work with interest and look forward to seeing further work bringing it forward .

I have considered that this is all fibro .

Substance P , the neurotransmiter involved in fibromyalgia is having lots of work done on it . It has been found that patients with fibro ahve a extra nerve pathway which means signals can be misdirected .
I am having a bit of a hard day so will come back to you soon Smiley Ive got loads to say xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Josie
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
missybean
Mentor
****
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 439
Washington
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #4 - 02/25/11 at 06:16:53
 
Josie, Could point me in the right direction to read some of Dr. Blancos work.
My mother in-law has Fibro and I am now wondering if she has some kind of mast cell thing going on because she has so many food sensitivities and the reactions she has are so similar to what I hear people describe on here.
I am just curious, I know there is all kinds of research stating different beliefs on what sets off Fibro and I have came across several that suggest a trauma or illness sets it off. I had a bad car accident at 18 and mono at 19. Did you guys have any kind of trauma or illness that happened to you and then shortly after symptoms of Fibro started?
Melissa
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Josie
Ex Member





Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #5 - 02/26/11 at 12:53:43
 
Hi malissa ,

The symptoms of fibromyalgia are in many ways similar to MCAS / MCAD . It is a diagnosis of exclusion . So all other rhumatology , neurological and immuno causes need to be excluded for it to be a true diagnosis .

In my case I think I have a little fibro and angiodeama . My cause for angiodeama is not established yet . All autoimmune causes have been excluded . I may have a new type of heridatory angiodeama . have you been tested for this ???

So my cause for my swelling may be histamine or type 3 HAE . Ill know more from my immuno next week .

I feel I have some fibro as I have had neck pains for many years which were treated happily with a massage and a night out Smiley So pure stress for me .

I was dignosed with fibro after 6 months of illness 2 days after my first shock . i was happily full of steriods and adrenaline so could move better than I had been with less pain that day .

2 weeks later my abdominal pain was very bad , my GP listened and reffered me on , so 2 weeks on he wasn't convinced . He was already suspecting "one of those funny syndromes where you react to alcohol " with my first shock .?? mastocytosis / mcas . But unf I had to move suddenly due to domestic violence and I had to leave his acre . A real set back for me in real terms .

I had a ( hospital )doc say all my symptoms were anxiety . I was a little upset that day because they had ordered a psych review without my consent . because they couldn't find out why i was shaking and being sick . well they did - gastritis .

I had been upset the week before on the first ward as i was left 2 hrs for anti sickness . The sister , when i told her my reasons , apologised but I didn't get an apology - anyway all in the past but so unfair and un necessary .

Now I have other explinations for most of my symptoms .
frequent urination - high BP , diabetes and prostoglandins .
pain = swelling ,
poor temp control - hot - histamine
retching - gastritis and bowel spasms
shaking - muscle spasms and dehydration - due to untreated retching

So I pace myself as I am told to do and have cool baths to help my back pain  . No fibro drugs helped .

My fibro friends have questioned the diagnosis as well as i didnt fit with them  even in how my pain behaves Smiley

So I remain open minded . On reading DR Blancos work I wandered if many fibro patients are undiagnosed mastocyctosis /  so that is why they have extra mast cells . But that's me tipping it on its head . With early work like Dr Blanco's it shows things , but it really creates more questions to research Smiley

Where are you in the getting a diagnosis process ???

If you do have masto or mcas it is not beyond that your family also have it . many of us have strong family histories , the research just needs to catch up with us .

I had a very stressful 6 months before my illness came out , culminating in taking a job in a well known fast food outlet for money as my sister was gambling . I do beleive this contributed to my illness coming out .
I presented with sweats , fatigue and temperture .
I had antibiotics and had pain in my liver and more sweats and shortness of breath on minimal exertion . I had a mild very mild chest infection . but i was very short of breath , now with knowledge , i suspect it was pollen ( summer ) and lots of kittens ( 11 inc big cats sleeping in my room ), personal care products ( short of breath in shower ) and bathroom cleaner which contributed to this first illness .

In the months before I had had I migraine which took me to ED (jan ) abdo bloating and retching ( may ) . All mysterious malladies .

I tolerated stress well before this . i was nursing for 15 yrs full time . I manged my stress as I said with hair dos , nights out and massages Smiley

My first epi pen experience was in Dec 08 , I had rose wine . flushed , red , had fast heart beat , dizzy and self presented at ED . i should ahve called an ambulance . But i got a lift . They saw me , got me into the resusitation room and treated me . I was very ill . BUT the treatment worked Smiley

I have had many experiences since then , shock , pain , operations , my bowel being so ill i was reacting to everything Sad

So please ask away .

Mono can make your immune system go bonkers without any true allergies where you have high IGE for that thing - mine are cats , house dust and grass pollen . Any physical ( operation , infection etc ) can un mask mast cell disease and angiodeama from other sources as all swelling is not necesserily mast cell based Smiley

hugs
Josie
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
missybean
Mentor
****
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 439
Washington
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #6 - 02/28/11 at 06:23:47
 
Josie, I got the fibro diagnoses in April of 2010 after a year and a half of seeing my Rhuemey. I had every dang test thinkable, she told me I was positive for all the trigger points so with that considered and process of elimination and my symptoms she felt that was the diagnoses of Fibro fit. I have the sleep problems fibro patients have frequent waking. She told me the different meds they use for fibro and she offered to prescribe them or if there was an antidepressant I had used before she would prescribe that. I had taken Wellbutrin before so she prescribed that. I'm not really sure if it helps or not, I have to say it helps with my anxiety and it helps me not to smoke a cigarette. I know bad stuff, I haven't smoked in a while but when I'm stressed I tend to want to sneak a puff here and there. I know bad, no lecturing. So the reason I question the diagnoses of fibro is when I avoid my triggers most of the symptoms are like 80% better. Still have the trigger points and the pain sensitivity so like if I barely bump into something it hurts when it shouldn't, sometimes it hurts just to hold me husbands hand.  
As far as the masto diagnoses, still awaiting a firm diagnoses. I had a skin biopsy at a dermatologist and was told it was telangiectasia and it was caused by heat and he sent me on my way.
I got a copy of the path report for myself and it showed that it also had a differential diagnoses of TMEP, so I saw another dermatologist for a second opinion and I believe she thought it was TMEP, she was real careful about what she said but she gave me a list of masto triggers and told me to stay away from my normal triggers and she has prescribed different meds including cromolyn which I just started. I asked the nurse, so does she think it is TMEP, and she said I think she wants to see how you respond to meds before she makes the final call. From what I understand about TMEP and what little information that is out there on the net is that it is a diagnoses that can not be made on lab results alone, clinical correlation is necessary and I believe it is pretty relevant that this some kind of mast cell thing. I have so many of the symptoms....Esophagitis, gastritis, IBS, olfactory hallucinations, chronic hives, heat induced hives, many food sensitivities, joint/muscle/bone pain, muscle fatigue, chemical sensitivities, multiple environmental allergies, too many to mention, I was allergic to like 65% of the trees, grasses, weeds, etc that they tested me for, and there is probably more I could list.
For me I can look back at my teenage years and having symptoms, flushing and alcohol intolerance, sweating fits followed by extreme itching. At 19 I swear I was going through menopause and had massive hormone work ups. Not really much, was told I had PCOS.
My appointment with the dermatologist is tomorrow and I'm wondering what she will say.
What was your diagnoses or are you still in progress? Are you still able to work?
Melissa
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Josie
Ex Member





Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #7 - 02/28/11 at 10:31:01
 
Hi mellisa ,

Oh babe , I compleltly understand xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx My pain is mostly conrolled by oxycodone . I was in teeth gritting pain every day.

My pain is also helped by less triggers . Masto wise - you need a more through work up . typtases , 24 hour urine collection for prostoglandins D2 , and a bone marrow biopsy ,
systemic mastocytosis can only be diagnosed by skin and or bone marrow biopsy to look at your mast cells there .
It can also affect all the things you describe . Did you ahve an oesophageal camera or a colconoscopy if so your samples from that could be re examined with a mast cell problem of the bowel in mind . It is known as mastocyctic entrocollitis .

Other conditions can have similar symptoms that need excluding . these are carciniod ( 5iiHA - 24 hour urine collection ideally by an oncologist as its a very slow growing and treatable cancer ) , pheaocrocythoma - catechlamines - epinepherine and nor epinepherire - 24 hr urine collection and heridatory angiodeama - compliment levels 1 , 3 ,4 .

A full autoimmune work up is also needed to make sure your problems arent being made worse by these .

mastocyctosis needs positive skin or bone marrow biopsy . But mast cell activation syndrome doesn't . as it about badly behaved normal mast cells . your true allergies may be triggering your other mast cells to join the party .

Singulair may help your chest symptoms . it has helped mine Smiley

gastrocrom is a good drug , that can take about 6 weeks to compleltly work . so be aptient chick xxxxx

I would ask Deb ( our leader xxxxxxxxxxxxxx ) about good immunologists that may be available for you to travel to .

Your dermo is doing well but I suspect you are on the edge of her knowledge . taking time , as long as she treats you is a good thing as it means you will get the right diagnosis . She can order the tests i said about . A tryptase would be helpful as well as it can direct re mastocyctosis .

I have a diagnosis of angiodeama , the nitty gritty is being sorted .

I ahve been tested for pheao , carciniod , HAE , tyhroid , adrenal and renal autoimmune disease as a cause . Lupus again . all negative .

So I may ahve HAE type 3 , new , and difficult to pin down .
I am seeing my immuno tomorrow . So ill let you know how it goes .

My tounge swells and my throat closes with a mix of swelling else were and blood pressure and pulse changes . I get wheezy . I flush regularly . I also ahve pale , sweaty , dizzy days , which I can help with anti histamines .

What meds are you on ?

I am in the same position as you foods wise . I am not going near , alcohol , vinigar , malt , caramel colour , malt o dextrin , sulphies in any form , gelatine , corn in any form ,
CT contrast , many meds ,
IGE allergies - cats , grass and house dust .


Fibro drugs wise you need to avoid any tricyclic antidepressants - amitrypylline , nor tryptyline . I didnt do well ( hives , flushing and swelling ) on cymbalta . Our serotonin levels can be high or low but don't respond well to being messed with .
Let me know how you go xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Josie

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
mikev
Guiding Light
***
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 188
st louis, mo
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #8 - 02/28/11 at 10:45:48
 
Josie/Melissa:
I too have symptoms in my skin sensitivity that are similar to fibro. My current GP, whose boss doc is a personal friend, is a rhumie & fibro guy subspeciality. He said he could not diagnose me as fibro because was too wide spread. That's when search went on until I found my allegist who did my tryptase test and found it inflated and gave me my SM diagnosis. Josie you right bumping into something can bring on pain that you almost come to tears. Touching can be very tough, what a terrible disease it is. Gastrocrom has helped some. Will be trying it w/ ketitofin soon as my sub comes in. To see if combo helps. Right now only tramadol gives relief and then just minor, as am Nasids intolerant & I do have it running in my family, grandma RA, Mom fibro-although I think she was misdiagnosed, daughter RA. Mine mainly in my feet which was the first part before went systemic, now my arms. & have a few triggers but mine seems to be more the filling the bucket. I would be shocked that if they didn't check further into fibro that's is roots are not in mast cells.
MikeV
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
missybean
Mentor
****
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 439
Washington
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #9 - 02/28/11 at 12:39:06
 
Josie- I do agree I need more of a masto work up. I did have a tryptase test, it came back 3.4. So that's good, I know I have a lot to learn but usually if it is systemic masto my tryptase level would probably be higher correct? I do believe my dermatologist's knowledge is probably limited. I have some info that was passed on to me about mast cell activation syndrome. I will be taking it with me and hopefully the doctor won't be offended if I give it to her. So really depending on what she says as far as diagnoses will depend on where I go next. If she does confirm TMEP then I know I need to find either a real good internal medicine doctor and an allergist/immunologist. I do have an immunologist I have seen a few times in Seattle, and he is supposed to be one of the best, but he didn't even know what TMEP was. I don't want to be to critical because it is a rare thing. But I did get a name of a doctor from some people in The Mast Cell support group for the Pacific Northwest.
I have had the carcinoid 24 hour urine test, I remember seeing work up's for CH50,CH100, C3, C4, ESR, CRP, CPK and Aldolase, Anti-Neutrophil Cytoplasmic AB full panel, Qual. Cryoglobulins, RA factor, ANA, Lupus panel, adrenal testing. The only thing that has come back positive is thyroid, I'm hypothyroid and the anticardiolipin(from lupus panel) has come back positive 3 times, but no lupus. RA factor was borderline, but they said it's not important. Autoimmune disease run in my family, my mom has three. So sometimes it scares me a little.
I had a colonoscopy and a endoscopy. They took samples during both but during the endoscopy he only took them for celiac, which was stupid because I had been gluten free for 7 months. He said I had some erosion at the GE Junction and esophageal inflammation, and gastritis Colonoscopy came back as IBS.
I'm so glad I didn't try the amitriptyline, I had a bad feeling in my gut. I had a friend on cymbalta and she went through withdrawls coming off that med, so I said no way. Right now I'm taking Zyrtec, generic zantac, cromolyn, and hydroxyzine and I have a prescription for singular ready to go.
Where do live Josie?
Melissa
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Josie
Ex Member





Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #10 - 03/01/11 at 02:02:31
 
Hi Mellisa .

I live in England , in Bristol a city in the south west .

I am glad you are being worked up . Even if they only looked for celiecs they maybe able to re examine them with mast cells in mind Smiley .

A normal trptases is seen a a completelrule out for mastcytosis . But masto can be present in very are cases ( Lisa ) But many of us has negative trptase with full symptoms .

This suggest either :- another cause for our symptoms or that we are not having constant raises but momentry ones during an attack we haven't caught yet Smiley Outside masto , only 30% od anaphylaxis shows tryptase rises , even in ppl who are dead due to shock . so typtase is a useful if its positive not useful otherwise kind of test Smiley

There are some good vids on you tube , which demonstarate things Smiley mast cell activation symptomology .

Autoimmune diease feels scary . the thing to remember is that treatment for all autoimmune diseases is getting better . Smiley You mum has lived through a time with minimal treatments .

Hypothyroid , in particaular hashimotos thyroidosis is a condition known to give extra compliment cascades , which makes you at risk of serious reactions . You should ask about thyroid pyroxidase antibodies . It may be in the tests done Smiley  

My appointment turned out to be a hello appt , which was ok , but I need action . feeling a bit ............... just now . I am getting my ambulance calls tp prove my airway compromise . yeah . thats about it for now Sad

Go for the singulair I love it and it has helped me a great deal Smiley

Hugs
Jose

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
missybean
Mentor
****
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 439
Washington
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #11 - 03/01/11 at 04:18:11
 
Thyroid antibodies huh? You know whats weird is my mom, grandma and I all had  thyroid goiters around the same age........our late 20's. We all have had a half of our thyroid removed.  
I really would like to know what caused that, no one has ever really explained to me, I was just told I need to take thyroid replacement.
One thing that is frustrated is no one will give me answers on why my hair is thinning, that started in 2004. Every year I feel like it's getting worse and worse.  No doctor can give me an answer. Both my parents and grandparents have thick hair, the men bald in their 50's. But mom and grandma.....full head of hair. I know in thyroid issues can cause thinning of hair but my numbers are good. ?????
I'm sorry your appointment didn't really give more answers. That can be so frustrating.
Today is my appointment and I hope I can get some answers. I will let you know how it goes.
Melissa
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
missybean
Mentor
****
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 439
Washington
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #12 - 03/01/11 at 04:44:28
 
Josie, I was thinking about your question about some other doctors continuing and building on Dr. Blancos research. There is a Pacific Northwest mast cell support group conference later this spring and I believe Dr. Overman who is a rheumatologist and co-wrote the book.... You Don’t LOOK Sick! Living Well With Invisible Chronic Illness is supposed to be a speaker at the conference and I believe will be speaking about Fibro. I will ask him about the spindle cell thing. I'll see what he has to say.
Melissa
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
larken
Guiding Light
***
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 136

Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #13 - 03/01/11 at 08:42:36
 
Hi Melissa,

I'm so glad to hear that another doctor is possibly researching fibro and mast cells.  I would love to hear what he has to say.  Please post if you are able to talk with him!  

I am talking with my doctor here in the Netherlands later this week and I hope he will speak with Dr. Blanco.  I'll let you know what he says about the spindle-shaped cells.  

Larken
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
missybean
Mentor
****
Offline


I Love YaBB 2!
Posts: 439
Washington
Re: Question about MCD and Fibromyalgia
Reply #14 - 03/01/11 at 09:01:12
 
I'm sorry Larken, I meant to address that to you. Brain Fog. Did you have spindle cells in your skin biopsy too? I remember mine mentioning spindle cells. I will post anything I find out. The conference isn't till the end of April. Did you get a masto diagnoses yet?
Melissa
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print